Hello There, Guest! Login Register


Poll: Yay or Nay?
It was amazing, best one lol
It was ok but I had deja vu
It made phantom menace look good
[Show Results]
 
Note: This is a public poll, other users will be able to see what you voted for.
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Force Awakens - Yay or Nay?
#1
I figured since I'm not lurking anymore I'd shame you all by creating the thread you all should've made already.

So yeah... Shame on you!

Anyway what did everyone think? I went in not expecting much as I simply don't understand why JJ is so revered like a modern Spielberg yet he's only really known for star trek which wasn't so great and Lost. And yeah... We all know how Lost turned out.

Personally I think when lucas said he wanted to mimic the originals he did, it just doesn't slap you in the face. JJ and the fans think he didn't so he had his own shot and ended up just remaking episode 4 with more plot holes. Also I counted 3 lense flares! God damn it JJ.

Anyway I guess that sums it up without going into full rant mode. At least people won't complain about the prequels just because its cool anymore. I hope.
 
Reply
#2
Well I liked itSmile

And welcome backSmile
 
Reply
#3
Haven't seen it yet, probably won't
#yolo
 
Reply
#4
I thought it was pretty damned good. Without spoilers; It follows the same formula as the original trilogy. In fact, at many points, you can cut, chop and paste the OT together and it'd play nearly the same as TFA. There were some disappointing aspects to it (much like Ultron in Age of Ultron) where you lose the fear of some characters, and he just becomes a baby with super powers. Really detracted from the impact of said character. Other than that; The acting a cut above any other Star Wars movie, and it was beautifully shot. The cinematography was excellent. In my opinion: There are now three amazing Star Wars flicks (#1 Empire, #2 are tied for Hope and Awakens).
 
Reply
#5
My wife liked it, which is amazing as she is pretty movie savy yet she hates SW... for me it harkened back to the oringal, just enough plot, lots of action and a cruel twist by the Dark Side!
 
Reply
#6
For me its ok but ... no new espectacular sounds, fx are just normal i mean in every new sw film there nice new sounds and amazing special effects, we are at 2016... this film lacks on all of this. As a sw fan i like the film yeah. But i thought would be more 2016 ish film rather than back to 90's... yeah films are not based on sound effects or fx... but we are talking about SW...
 
Reply
#7
Smile 
I'm new to ModtheGalaxy, so hello  Smile

I thought the movie wasn't up to snuff for several reasons.

1. No scale - a resistance battle consisting of a handful of X-wings is hardly on the scale of Star Wars, the real life locations used as foreign "planets" was bad in that it didn't encapsulate the feel of a large and expansive universe.
2. Useless plot progression - scene with ball monsters had no purpose in film.
3. Bad dialogue for original cast, the dialogue between Leia and Solo is terrible.
4. Cheesy repetitive villains (Kylo and Snoke makes a bad combo and we've seen that mix before between vulnerable but manipulative/encompassing Sith Lord with conflicted Apprentice)
5. The whole "I will finished what Darth Vader started" - What did Vader start? He brought balance to the force as the "chosen one", he created a galaxy with 2 Jedi and 2 Sith which ended up with 1 Jedi (Luke) who was a "grey" Jedi meaning he seemed to hold a balance between Dark and Light. He certainly didn't start anything either, he was Palpatine's goon, if anyone was starting something is was good old Palps.
6. Kylo Ren is an awful character and he simple states his emotions in the film rather than demonstrating through effective dialogue. There was more emotion and conflicted feeling felt in the blank face mask of Darth Vader in Episode VI than Kylo could ever portray.




There was quite a few things like this that didn't wow me; because of this I certainly like Episode I way more than VII. Can't use Jar Jar as a bash reason for not liking Ep. I either; Jar Jar, and the Gungans were no different than the comic relief of BB8 or the Ewoks - really the Ewoks and BB8 are much worse in my opinion with regards to goofiness.
 
Reply
#8
How nice of you to login.
Viaron
 
Reply
#9
Shame on you Valky.

Honestly I think plotholes is completely justifiable. I haven't read the novelization but I hear it makes a lot of the things in the movies seem even worse. For example it states the empire is under trade restrictions and being monitored heavily by the new republic. Considering that why the hell would they turn a blind eye to them building a super weapon capable of destroying multiple planets at the same time lol? Also under those conditions why does the empire seem to have gotten much more tech'd up compared to the jump from the prequels to the originals in which you could argue in some ways they got lower tech.

I pretty much agree with all of your points Himalayas. The way the original characters interacted with each other was laughable. I felt like they didn't read the script back even once. There is a particular moment (trying not to post any clear spoilers) after a certain dramatic demise where a certain furball is completely ignored in favor of the new cast getting some emotional screen time which made no sense. I can't speak for Snoke, as if he does turn out to be Plagueis it could save the next film for me, but Kylo was by far the weakest and most pathetically developed villain in the franchise. The focus on Vader's deeds scares me about the future. I'm in favor of the expanded universe but clone palpy was a bad call even in the EU, I hope we aren't gonna see an anakin clone. For the locations they could have at least used new planets not obvious clones of  tatooine, hoth and yavin. The forest one may have actually been an area on Yavin 4 but I wasn't really paying attention anymore at that point so I'm guessing it was just another clone.

All in all I fully agree. Episode 1 is by far a better film. You take away Jar Jar and 3po and its not at all a bad story. The new film might be lacking any irritating characters but it certainly doesn't have a true story like all the other films, no matter how many flaws they all have. I also agree with BB8 being a bit too silly. But I suspect we are one of the few. I actually hate 3PO and Jar Jar equally. I found 3PO to be just as irritating in the originals as Jar Jar is in the prequels and the same comparison definitely fits regarding ewoks and gungans.

I don't think the FX were "bad" in terms of quality, but they made it clear it was a JJ film which I didn't like. As a whole it just didn't feel like Star Wars anymore to me. If Snoke turns out to be just some random ugly guy instead of Plagueis then there will honestly be nothing linking these films to the previous plot in which case I may just pass on episode 8 and 9 entirely.

EDIT: One compliment I will give is the new cast did a good job, Kylo excluded although part of that is bad writing and direction. They were all much more convincing characters than most of the characters in the previous films and I think they all gave good performances. A lot of people say Harrison Ford stole the show but honestly as one of the few actors who was good in the original I think the new kids out-performed him.
 
Reply
#10
(2016-01-31, 08:23 PM)Tonberry Wrote: Shame on you Valky.

Honestly I think plotholes is completely justifiable. I haven't read the novelization but I hear it makes a lot of the things in the movies seem even worse. For example it states the empire is under trade restrictions and being monitored heavily by the new republic. Considering that why the hell would they turn a blind eye to them building a super weapon capable of destroying multiple planets at the same time lol? Also under those conditions why does the empire seem to have gotten much more tech'd up compared to the jump from the prequels to the originals in which you could argue in some ways they got lower tech.

I pretty much agree with all of your points Himalayas. The way the original characters interacted with each other was laughable. I felt like they didn't read the script back even once. There is a particular moment (trying not to post any clear spoilers) after a certain dramatic demise where a certain furball is completely ignored in favor of the new cast getting some emotional screen time which made no sense. I can't speak for Snoke, as if he does turn out to be Plagueis it could save the next film for me, but Kylo was by far the weakest and most pathetically developed villain in the franchise. The focus on Vader's deeds scares me about the future. I'm in favor of the expanded universe but clone palpy was a bad call even in the EU, I hope we aren't gonna see an anakin clone. For the locations they could have at least used new planets not obvious clones of  tatooine, hoth and yavin. The forest one may have actually been an area on Yavin 4 but I wasn't really paying attention anymore at that point so I'm guessing it was just another clone.

All in all I fully agree. Episode 1 is by far a better film. You take away Jar Jar and 3po and its not at all a bad story. The new film might be lacking any irritating characters but it certainly doesn't have a true story like all the other films, no matter how many flaws they all have. I also agree with BB8 being a bit too silly. But I suspect we are one of the few. I actually hate 3PO and Jar Jar equally. I found 3PO to be just as irritating in the originals as Jar Jar is in the prequels and the same comparison definitely fits regarding ewoks and gungans.

I don't think the FX were "bad" in terms of quality, but they made it clear it was a JJ film which I didn't like. As a whole it just didn't feel like Star Wars anymore to me. If Snoke turns out to be just some random ugly guy instead of Plagueis then there will honestly be nothing linking these films to the previous plot in which case I may just pass on episode 8 and 9 entirely.

EDIT: One compliment I will give is the new cast did a good job, Kylo excluded although part of that is bad writing and direction. They were all much more convincing characters than most of the characters in the previous films and I think they all gave good performances. A lot of people say Harrison Ford stole the show but honestly as one of the few actors who was good in the original I think the new kids still managed to out-perform him.
 
Reply
  



Forum Jump:


Browsing: 1 Guest(s)